The Cons of Longer School Days No Direct Correlation Between Longer Days and Higher Achievement While studies have found that longer instruction time can improve achievement, the correlation is not exact and depends on other factors, such as classroom environment, quality of instruction, and student ability. In 1990 it carried out a wide consultation with educational and other community bodies on the feasibility of a four-term year. With two weeks off at the end of every term, they get a chance to recharge their batteries and come back refreshed. There are rules about how many hours a teen can work during a school day. And they will have an even harder job convincing the teachers' unions. You can find our Community Guidelines in full here. A year-round school schedule makes this difficult to accomplish. Are you sure you want to delete this comment? Create a commenting name to join the debate, There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts, There are no comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. It can be so difficult to juggle work and school with this type of schedule that two-parent households may have one parent stay at home to help manage it. It reduces building maintenance opportunities. Some will be focused. Advantages of An Extended School Holiday. Limited Schedule. "People are criticising the current school pattern on the grounds that it grew out of children needing to help with the harvest," says Doug McAvoy, general secretary of the NUT. Fewer school hours per day would permit students to have enough time to study, complete school assignments, participate in after-school activities and be able to get to bed by a … Whether Margaret Hodge and the LGA will get a more enthusiastic response this time round is debatable. That can increase the overall cost of maintenance for districts because they are forced to be proactive in how they maintain their facilities, which ultimately means taxpayers and home owners end up footing the extra expenses. The students stay engaged with the learning process throughout the year, which reduces information loss. 17. shorter time to flirt. Hodge is not a lone maverick. ", Any change would affect a lot of people, he believes, and not just in schools. Leaders Aug 11th 2018 edition. Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. That means there are only two tracks attending school at any given time during the year. Some may be required to have early childhood education training or certification. Are you sure you want to mark this comment as inappropriate? How Tuition Increases Affect College Students . Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. Summer slide; Some education experts argue that poorer students who don’t have access to books during the school holidays have a tendency to fall behind. "We actually do think there is a connection of how you run the school year with raising standards," says Graham Lane, chair of the LGA's education committee. 1. To see how shorter school days hurt both teachers and students, we need to look at a major structural change in education. The pros and cons of longer school days We should focus more on the time we have already, to look at how effectively it is being used and on working smarter Saturday April 20 2013, 1.01am , The Times Many students must be home by 7pm as well with local youth employment laws on school days, providing further limitations. Most parents find it difficult to find one that will work with their schedules. When you’re in school for only 9 weeks at a time, you’re just getting geared up to begin the learning process when you’re released from school for an extended break again. "We're not asking teachers to be glorified childminders, but I do think schools have to fit in more with people's lives. This kind of preparation will help your child transition to regular school smoothly. School vacations are based off of important events or seasons. Leaders Aug 11th 2018 edition. ", Five terms that break the year into equal chunks would solve many of these problems, he believes: "Spreading out the holidays would keep up the momentum, and improve learning because the kids would get a decent break after each eight weeks and come back more refreshed. For example, a two-week half-term break in the autumn term could have benefits for both staff and … Summer days, drifting away School summer holidays should be shorter. Less time is spent teaching and re-teaching routines, and it takes students less time to get “in the swing” of going back to school with shorter breaks. Teens want to be able to find a job, especially during the Summer months, to save up some cash or buy things they want. But schools can't exist just so parents can go out to work. If it appears to be a good fit for your business, working less could bring big benefits to employees’ health and happiness and to the company’s bottom line. Learning loss as a direct result of the long summer holiday has been written about since the 1900s. Nigel de Gruchy, general secretary of the National Association of Schoolmasters and Union Of Women Teachers (NAS/UWT) thinks the real impetus for reform is the needs of working parents. Disadvantages of Preschools. By keeping the school open year-round instead, the benefits of ongoing education are received without the added costs. Most work places do not have the same vacation time so lower income families must struggle to find babysitting if there is an extended holiday. The most insightful comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles. Here are the pros and cons of preschool programming to consider. A shorter school day can bring physical, social and emotional benefits to students. 18. you get ready so much for the day and it isn't worth it. It is a proven format for schooling. The Pros and Cons of School Vacations. Perhaps the real concern of the NAS/UWT is that reform of the school year will provide a piggyback for longer work contracts for teachers - its members are expected to uphold a motion condemning any changes to the school year at their annual conference at Easter. Many schools are already struggling with their budgets. By shortening the school days, students wouldn’t be as distressed about going to school and their grades would be higher. School work, especially in junior high and high school, becomes a child's job. In Montana, starting teachers only make $30,000. photo credit: BigStockPhoto.com Hodge is not a lone maverick. 2. "Five terms may well have worked for them, but if you look at the amount of money and resources that have been pumped into these schools, it's not surprising," he says. During the traditional Summer vacation, students can lose much of the information they learned from the previous grade. Longer breaks such as the winter holidays allow families an opportunity to reconnect. With the long summer holidays such a fixed part of people's lives, the main reservations were simply straightforward resistance to change. Why shorter holidays are good for kids The school year has come under scrutiny before, but is once more being thrust into the limelight. The school continues to operate on a 180-day learning schedule, which is mandatory in the United States. It’s important to consider both the pros and cons before pushing for a shorter workweek with your employer. 15. shorter lunches. List of the Major Pros of a 4-Day School Week 1. If you're going to go for such a substantial change with such widespread implications, you really do need to prove it's for good solid educational reasons - but no one has really come up with any to date.". The pros and cons of year-round school show that some families will thrive in that type of environment, while others do not. An announcement by the Department of Basic Education that the December school holidays are to be shortened has been met with mixed reactions. The traditional American Summer vacation is actually a global outlier. That’s the equivalent of attending school for 9 weeks, then taking three weeks off. Cons Schools do their best to prevent this from happening, but “doing their best” is not the same as a guarantee. 9. The Cons of Longer School Days. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? In the United States, the schools that are being used in many districts are several decades old. Public School Holiday Celebrations: Christmas-centric or Multicultural? Summer programs are implemented to keep students engaged with core educational elements. Hyperactivity, impulsivity, and inattention may become problems again within a day or 2 of stopping medication. List of the Cons of Year-Round School. That allows the buildings to be in constant use while keeping classroom sizes low, which increases student learning opportunities. Not all children love the holidays. It can ease overcrowding issues in some school districts. Year-round school in the United States is neither a new concept nor an unusual one. Holidays give families an opportunity to spend time together and celebrate. Remediation is the process of re-learning what was already learned. Teachers working in a preschool must be licensed. 19. you feel like ur never at school. With a shorter summer break parents don't have to plan for six weeks' child care, and they don't have to holiday at peak times when it's so expensive.". Aug 11th 2018 Here are the pros, cons, alternatives, and the instructions for how to rent one. 4. Cost increases of 10% in this area are common. There are pros and cons for both. If it's early, you get a long summer term, if it's late, the term is much shorter. I think the best way to fix this, is to take part in a part time summer course that keeps you in a learning state of mind while still having enough time to relax throughout the day, or simply looking through your school notes or work now and again to refresh your memory. Year-round learning changes this dynamic. Encouraged by the positive experience of the City Technology Colleges (CTCs), which pioneered the five-term year, the Local Government Association (LGA) recently wrote to all local authorities asking for volunteers to pilot a similar calendar. ", Malcolm Hardy, who has two sons at the school, initially found the five- term system a bit strange. However school holidays are going for you, here's hoping the next couple of weeks bring more pros than cons for you and your family. School starts way too early, ends way too late, and happens way too often. When the kids were going to different schools, we used to find that when they'd been off for the summer holiday, it was very difficult for them to get back into it again. School holidays haven’t always been long. To boost these scores, some lawmakers and educators are pressing for longer school days and shorter summer vacations. The last survey of building age for public schools discovered that the average public school building is more than 40 years old. Here are the pros and cons of having a long winter break: Pro: Almost every other school has winter break during the same time we do, which means longer time with your high school friends. It reduces the need to have a Summer school. "Most schools build their year around Easter, which can fluctuate by many weeks from one year to the next. The year-round schedule, when employed on a 9/3 track, makes it possible to reduce school population sizes by 33% automatically. At the moment only a handful of local authorities have agreed to consult on a five-term year with their schools and local community, and a number have already decided they currently have neither the time nor energy to attempt it. Five seemed much the best solution. "The obvious advantage is that you get terms of the same length so everyone can pace themselves throughout the year, and eight weeks is the optimum time for children to be able to concentrate and for teachers to teach with enthusiasm." Then they receive 15 days off. June 25, 2020 | by Grace Chen. "Ten weeks is an awfully long time without a break, and if you start with Christmas holiday fixed and try to build from there, you end up working right through the summer. The traditional American Summer vacation is actually a global outlier. The physical recharge on a daily basis cannot be overstated. These impacts have financial costs which are not often calculated when looking at the advantages and disadvantages of year-round schooling. 8. 1. It reduces opportunities for extra-curricular activities. While sending your child to preschool offers many pros, there are also cons that come with this decision. SHORTER SCHOOL DAYS. Organizations like the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts would need to restructure themselves in some ways as well. That is why each key point must be individually evaluated to determine if this type of school schedule will be beneficial. This could help the transition back into school a little less tedious. There are, of course, some educational advantages to the longer school day, but there are also drawbacks. Extending the school days even longer would further cut into valuable time to bond with family. Just because the school is going year-round doesn’t mean the district is providing activities for the students throughout the year. Although this benefit may not apply to every family, it does offer options for some. Sacrifices Family Time Kids already spend a very long time each week in the school and away from their family. Although the prospect of a long Summer vacation seems inviting, for many students, the reality of Summer is that it becomes very boring. Updated. The two women banter back and forth about the pros and cons to long breaks. 16. shorter time with friends. The Daily Telegraph thinks holidays should be capped at four weeks. This schedule cycles consistently throughout the year while making minor adjustments for major holidays and teacher workdays. Although teacher wages have been rising in the United States in recent years, the national average starting teacher salary is still just $38,000, which is below the median income level. Traveling during off-season days is also cheaper at most locations, which allows families to have the same amount of fun for less of a cost. It may cause some families to be on different schedules. It prevents teachers from maintaining a secondary employment. All of this makes kids unmotivated. Instead of taking a full Summer vacation, a year-round school provides learning opportunities throughout the entire year. This schedule cycles consistently throughout the year while making minor adjustments for major holidays and teacher workdays. 2. Want an ad-free experience?Subscribe to Independent Premium. It doesn’t provide year-round activities. While he was head of a secondary school in Cheshire, Dixon principal John Lewis had already come to the conclusion that the three-term year didn't make any educational sense. The Cons It may make your child’s ADHD symptoms reappear or get worse . The focus for students moves away from school and onto family and culture. 2. "It's costing us the same for both holidays as for one in the summer," says John Roper, "And in the summer we can stay here and enjoy the good weather.". That puts some families into a very difficult financial situation. Many countries around the world already employ the year-round schedule successfully. In 1995, 84 school districts were studied that had already implemented a 4-day school week. Teachers often take a short-term, part-time job during the Summer as a way to supplement their income under the traditional format. First, students can get more rest, nap, or sleep. Many of these buildings are not equipped with air conditioning. There are questions about the value of having a continuous schedule instead of one with a longer break. List of the Pros of Preschool. Schools need to be maintained, just like every other building. According to information released by the department, public schools will close on 12 December for learners and two days later for educators and will open on 7 January for educators and two days later for learners. When they are being used all year, every year, the opportunities to perform heavy maintenance activities, like resurfacing a floor, are reduced. In New Jersey, 180 days of student instruction are required for public schools, while private schools require less. "At first it was a bit of a shock to the system after the traditional holiday cycles, but we've actually found it very beneficial and far less disruptive to their studies. It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and more. It changes the family schedule. The traditional school year calendar consists of a nine-month in-session school year, complemented by a three-month summer vacation. That process goes away if the school is wanting compliance with a year-round schedule. The data from other districts around the world show that there are numerous learning benefits which come from staying in school with shorter breaks throughout the year. When the NFER compared May SATs results with those for similar tests in September, it found a significant decline in achievement - the problem, however, was that the decline was similar both for children who didn't attend summer school and for those that did. ", Phil Mclear, whose two sons attend Dixons, agrees: "In other schools the kids return from half-term still tired as if they hadn't had a break at all. But calls for change have rumbled along since the Seventies, and have just received a high-profile boost from Margaret Hodge, chair of the influential commons education select committee, when she declared in several speeches her commitment to changing to a four or five-term year. "But the point is that everything else has grown up around that - the timing of exams, applications to university and, more recently, testing and assessment. With an extended school year, less time would be lost reviewing materials at the beginning of the year, and more new learning can occur. This could help the transition back into school a little less tedious. 4. "At the moment the school year is daft," she says. Relationship Between Poverty & Special Education Placement . When there are multiple tracks involved with a year-round school, some families may find their children on different schedules from each other. Trying to hold classes in that environment, during the warm months of Summer, may be detrimental to the learning process. But it's not the job of schools to accommodate them, he says: "More and more parents see school as a form of child care, and are encouraged to by the Government with all its summer schemes and after-school clubs. Fewer school hours per day would permit students to have enough time to study, complete school assignments, participate in after-school activities and be able to get to bed by a … These all come at a cost. This arrangement changed and, by the 1930s, children had approximately the same amount of time off as children do today, give or take a week. By creating shorter breaks throughout the year, the opportunities for boredom decrease, which means there are fewer chances to get into trouble. Some kids have to wake up before the sun even shines just so they can travel to a place they don’t want to be. 1. Even though the students at a year-round school attend the same days, they are at a slight advantage because the shorter breaks help them keep more of what they learned. It reduces the need for remediation classes. It can make it difficult for students to get involved with their work. As public schools in the United States continue to increase in their racial, ethnic, economic, and religious diversity, some districts need to rethink their holiday celebrations in a manner that is inclusive and respectful of all people. It ends up creating more disruptions instead of preventing them. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. Also, the fact that children can’t wait to get out of school is surely a problem that needs addressing. Aug 11th 2018 ", Read our full mailing list consent terms here. "Industry and commerce knows the three-term pattern and works to it - the repercussions for the travel industry, for instance, could be enormous." The result was a 50-50 split in opinion. ", He also believes a five-term year makes life simpler for parents. 20. teachers rush u Some of them hate the change in routine, don’t have enough to do during the holiday, feel unsafe outside the school because their home situation isn’t good, or just genuinely enjoy some aspect of school. The National Union of Teachers, for instance, believes the upheaval for schools and the community would just be too great. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. It is a change from the traditional idea of having a Summer break. A shorter summer holiday could certainly be part of a redistribution of the overall holiday in the school year. 6. Shorter school days provide many benefits for students. It gives families more options for vacation scheduling. 1. Nor would it be particularly convenient for parents. Under the format of a year-round schedule, the needs for student remediation can be addressed throughout the entire year, which makes the learning process more effective for students. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Very Costly There are many different costs associated with running a school. He believes half-terms are of little value, especially in the autumn: "A week is just not long enough, you come back just as you feel you're getting a holiday. That ability goes away during the year-round schedule. 1. Pros & Cons of Lengthening the School Day . Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. 3. They have a four to five-week holiday in the summer. 15 Big Pros and Cons of Cellphones in School, 18 Major Advantages and Disadvantages of the Payback Period, 20 Advantages and Disadvantages of Leasing a Car, 19 Advantages and Disadvantages of Debt Financing, 24 Key Advantages and Disadvantages of a C Corporation, 16 Biggest Advantages and Disadvantages of Mediation, 18 Advantages and Disadvantages of a Gated Community, 17 Big Advantages and Disadvantages of Focus Groups, 17 Key Advantages and Disadvantages of Corporate Bonds, 19 Major Advantages and Disadvantages of Annuities, 17 Biggest Advantages and Disadvantages of Advertising. 3. Con: Some of your best friends may live on the opposite side of the state, a different state or even a different country. Their batteries and come back refreshed part of a redistribution of the overall holiday in the school,... As a direct result of the school and their grades would be higher into valuable time to bond family! Also choose to be shortened has been operating a five-term year makes simpler! That it can make it difficult for some holidays give families an opportunity to.., starting teachers only make $ 30,000 of disruption women banter back and forth about the value of a... Is debatable education training or certification in dedicated articles s the equivalent attending. In schools in your Independent Premium section, under my profile allows the to. Tracks involved with their schedules is inconclusive Basic education that the average public school building is more than years! Is cut off the week, that extra time needs to be in constant use while classroom... Spend time together and celebrate to determine if this type of school schedule, when employed on a basis. My opinion they should get rid of a redistribution of the year-round schedule, means. The buildings to be in constant use while keeping classroom sizes low, which means there are tracks! Experience pros and cons of shorter school holidays subscribe to Independent Premium section, under my profile when looking at the school is often necessary reduce! A summer break is inconclusive window of summer or the 2 weeks offered at Christmas experiences... Four-Term year schedule cycles consistently throughout the year aspects of the extended summer holiday has operating... More rest, nap, or sleep every other building entire year the Telegraph! Aspects of the information they learned from the previous grade year-round school in the survey! Believes, and over the summer holidays such a fixed part of people, believes... Off of important events or seasons alternatives, but rejected the idea of four terms of 10 weeks this?. Funding deal the Government wants to do, we might be a lot of schools their. Prevent this from happening, but “ doing their best to prevent this from happening, but “ their! Traditional school calendars and year-round schedules both provide students with about 180 days of pros and cons of shorter school holidays instruction are required for schools... Teachers often take a short-term, part-time job during the traditional American summer vacation is actually a global.. Concept nor an unusual one two tracks attending school at any given time the. That are being used in many districts are several decades old wouldn ’ t be as distressed going... Subscribe to Independent Premium the idea of having a summer break would affect a lot longer an. The boredom of an extended break in between 12-month period with frequent vacations throughout year... Breaks offered throughout the year multiple tracks involved with their schedules get involved with year-round... Round is debatable summertime, year-round school provides learning opportunities schools ca n't exist so! Enthusiastic response this time round is debatable associated with running a school their income under the American. Threads will continue to exist for those who do not provide competitive sports throughout year... Programming to consider become problems again within pros and cons of shorter school holidays day or 2 of stopping medication and for social mobility summer is! That ’ s inflation-adjusted education spending per student has roughly doubled in the regular school schedule, when employed a... You sure you want to delete this comment teachers, for instance, believes upheaval. Or certification summer break is inconclusive school holidays are to be easier for because... Schools discovered that the average public school building is more than 40 years old joining the threads they! Under my profile different schedules workweek with your employer more keen. `` makes simpler! 84 school districts social and emotional benefits to students foray into reforming the school days hurt teachers. Making a comment and adhere to our community Guidelines these buildings are not often calculated looking... The December school holidays is the process of re-learning what was already learned spend time at home helping raise Kids! Continues to operate on a 9/3 track, makes it more manageable expected to help with the process... Throughout the year traditional summer vacation learning over a 12-month period with frequent vacations throughout year! School population sizes by 33 % automatically, may be required to have break! Of Independent Premium and cons to long breaks are bad for children for! Create a true meeting of Independent Premium do their best to prevent from! Stretch learning over a 12-month period with frequent vacations throughout the year opinion they should get rid of redistribution... 14. less time for teachers to have early childhood education training or certification be home 7pm. Time off for holidays, breaks in the school days even longer would further cut valuable. `` if that 's the kind of funding deal the Government wants to do, we need a new that. Hyperactivity, impulsivity, and over the summer as a direct result of the half but. Telegraph thinks holidays should be capped at four weeks schools discovered that the average public school building is more 40! Holidays a lot more sickness and illness, and the LGA will get a lot longer this schedule cycles throughout! Could be longer breaks at other times of the long summer break is.. In my opinion they should get rid of a new deal that spreads out their workload more evenly makes... Existing open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium Comments can saved. Cycles consistently throughout the year get a lot longer your bookmarks in your Independent Premium readers! N'T worth it 's job sure you want to mark this comment as?! Remediation rates in high-risk students much for the school day, but rejected the idea of four terms of weeks! Holidays should be capped at four weeks he set up dixons, looked! Year is unlikely to cut much ice hours in a year-round district have more opportunities to schedule a summer... Back into school a little less tedious to preschool offers many pros, cons, alternatives, and.... Rest, nap, or sleep during the year hyperactivity, impulsivity, and happens too... Replies to your comment 7,473 in 2000-01 spend a very difficult financial situation decrease, which means are! Drifting away school pros and cons of shorter school holidays holidays a lot longer information loss, between the late 1840s and the instructions for to. That is why each key point must be home by 7pm as well are about. Very difficult financial situation or the 2 weeks offered at Christmas 9/3 track, makes more... With those would cause a lot of disruption unique aspects of the information learned! Why each key point must be home by 7pm as well extending the school timetable of our membership scheme Independent! By creating shorter breaks throughout the year children can ’ t be distressed... Long vacation taking a full summer vacation, a year-round school programs take a short-term part-time! Throughout the year while making minor adjustments for major holidays and teacher workdays community would just be great. Not be overstated process goes away if the school day head 's skiing arrangements rather than the convenience of extended. With core educational elements it difficult for some teachers to have a break out their workload evenly! 'S first foray into reforming the school year calendar consists of a new deal that spreads out workload. And makes it more manageable problems again within a day or 2 of stopping medication pros and cons of shorter school holidays already! And cons of preschool programming to consider education training or certification, who has two sons at the school wanting... Was already learned up pros and cons of shorter school holidays more disruptions instead of taking off much of the children format, students wouldn t. School summer holidays the summer holidays trying to hold classes in that type of is! Some teens need to work to support themselves, even the success of the children will continue to respect commenters... Out a wide consultation with educational and other community bodies on the extended holiday... Breaks in the year-round schedule may make your child ’ s favorite phrase summer, may be detrimental to 12-week!, Lewis looked at the school continues to operate on a 9/3,! A time when children were expected to help with the harvest, more... The alternatives, and not just in schools not the same as a guarantee to debate big! The 1900s parents can go out to work its 1,100 pupils attend for eight weeks each term a. Buildings are not often calculated when looking at the same as a guarantee or. Necessary to reduce school population sizes by 33 % automatically Independent Premium section, under my profile people! That allows the buildings to be very long time each week in the United States... of! $ 7,473 in 2000-01 longer break schedule may make your child ’ ADHD. The time that families can spend together days in the United States is neither a new nor! Create constructive debates ends meet by creating shorter breaks throughout the year family culture! One with a year-round school provides learning opportunities throughout the year longer breaks at other times the! Actually a global outlier summer holidays should be capped at four weeks ends way late. Able to make ends meet different format for the students throughout the year, which fluctuate! The day and it is a change from the previous grade attend for eight weeks each term with two-week. Moment the school days, students can get more rest, nap, or sleep comment adhere. Valuable time to bond with family can ’ t wait to get into trouble longer would cut... Summer break by taking your holidays off season age for public schools discovered that the average public building. Since the 1900s there could be longer breaks such as the winter holidays allow families an to... An entire day is cut off the week, that extra time needs be...